Consent, consultation and politics

Dr Jim Green
Crikey! letters

 

Federal resources minister Martin Ferguson's announcement on Tuesday that he will pursue plans for a national nuclear waste dump at the Muckaty site, north of Tennant Creek in the NT, continues the shabby and unfair process set in train by the Howard government.

Mr Ferguson's media release falsely claims that the nomination of the Muckaty site has the support of the Ngapa Traditional Owners. He well knows that many Ngapa Traditional Owners oppose the dump; for example he was sent a letter opposing the dump in May 2009 signed by 25 Ngapa Traditional Owners and 33 Traditional Owners from other Muckaty groups.

Mr Ferguson is also well aware of the unanimous resolution passed by the NT Labor Conference in April 2008 which called on the federal government to exclude Muckaty on the grounds that the nomination of the site "was not made with the full and informed consent of all Traditional Owners and affected people and as such does not comply with the Aboriginal Land Rights Act".

Mr Ferguson should repeal the nomination of the Muckaty site and start from scratch with an inquiry into all the options available for managing Australia's radioactive waste, including the option of ongoing storage at the Lucas Heights nuclear reactor site - the source of most of the waste and most of Australia's radioactive waste management expertise.


More articles in this section ...